The BC Conservatives have different priorities to the outgoing NDP government. They should make them clear to BC Hydro and the BCUC.
Manifesto destiny
The new BC Conservative government promised in its pre-election manifesto to add “reliability” to the province’s legislated Energy Objectives. On its face, this isn’t terribly controversial. Who wouldn’t want their energy supply to be reliable?
But the Conservatives want to “ensure that BC always has the energy it needs, when it needs it, and can accommodate growth without increasing energy costs on consumers.”
It’s too much to hope that simply adding reliability as a legislated Energy Objective will achieve these goals. But the Energy Objectives are an important foundation for the real improvements we need, and there are plenty more changes that could be made.
Let’s take a look at how updated Energy Objectives might affect the electricity sector, and in particular BC Hydro, the provincially-owned electric utility, and the BC Utilities Commission (BCUC), its economic regulator.
Background
BC’s legislated Energy Objectives were originally set out in the 2010 Clean Energy Act, and were subsequently modified by an Order in Council in 2024. They apply to all forms of energy, but have a significant electricity bias (hence the focus of this article).
The Energy Objectives currently in place are set out in Attachment 1 below, and include electricity self-sufficiency, competitive BC Hydro rates, reduced greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and economic development, all without using nuclear power.
The Energy Objectives provide a formal and transparent set of policy goals for the BCUC to follow when making decisions “in the public interest”, a term not defined in the Utilities Commission Act. Such a strong form of policy communication should be reviewed by an incoming party to ensure it aligns with their views.
One of the most important public-interest tasks the BCUC undertakes is to review BC Hydro’s long-term plan to meet electricity demand in the province. The Energy Objectives influence how the plan is developed, and whether the BCUC will accept it. (They are also used to evaluate specific capital projects, such as new generation plants, and energy purchases, e.g. buying wind power from the private sector.)
Adding reliability
The Conservatives’ proposal to add reliability as an Energy Objective is quite reasonable. In some ways it’s an odd omission from the current list, but the Utilities Commission Act already requires utilities to provide reliable service, so perhaps it was thought unnecessary to include it.
Regardless, it is important that BC Hydro considers reliability in its long-term planning. Adding large amounts of wind or solar power, clean but unreliable sources of generation, could destabilize the grid if not done properly.
To be fair, BC Hydro does appear to take reliability seriously. It plans according to the well-established “loss-of-load” standard: i.e., being unable to serve peak demand less than one day in ten years. Given that no system is ever completely reliable, that reliability standard seems adequate.
But it’s not clear how BC Hydro goes about “meeting” the standard. Is it in fact exceeding the standard, by spending more than it needs to? And electricity systems have moved on since the standard was developed in the 1970s, can it be met more cheaply?
These are reasonable questions to ask, and for several years BC Hydro has contemplated changing its reliability standard. But the BCUC’s recent review of BC Hydro’s 2025 plan showed little interest in the subject, merely asking for an update on its discussions by the end of 2028. Perhaps if reliability was a legislated Energy Objective, the regulator would take a more active interest.
So, by all means, add reliability to the list. But what else could be done?
It’s the economy, s****d
To start with, the new government should reset the priorities.
Originally, all BC’s Energy Objectives were of equal priority. It was up to the BCUC to determine whether a utility’s long-term plan was, on balance, in the public interest. The BCUC was expected to consider broader government policy, but also to use its own judgement.
The former NDP government decided in 2024 to be more specific. It amended the law to give the highest priority to reducing GHG emissions and keeping BC Hydro’s electricity rate increases below cumulative inflation. All other Energy Objectives were secondary.
The Conservatives could also be more specific, according to their own agenda. The highest priorities in their manifesto appear to be:
- electricity self-sufficiency;
- competitive BC Hydro rates;
- economic development; and
- reliability (the proposed new objective).
The other Energy Objectives would still be considered in utility planning, but to the extent there are trade-offs, the new government’s policy priorities would carry more weight. It appears from the Conservatives’ plan, for example, that reducing GHG emissions is now a lower priority, at least in the short term.
Prioritizing electricity self-sufficiency probably doesn’t add a lot, as BC Hydro is already required under the Clean Energy Act to be self-sufficient (although that requirement isn’t as strong as it appears to be). But leaving it off the priority list would be confusing.
Likewise, reliability is already a requirement of the Utilities Commission Act, but it would be clearer if it were also on the priority list.
But giving higher priority to economic development could make a real difference. It would be consistent with the new government’s desire to expand generation, supporting new mines, ports, data centres and the like which require large amounts of electricity to create the wealth and jobs we need in the province.
The rates question
The new government wants to do all this without increasing energy consumers’ costs. I fear they will be disappointed, as BC Hydro’s costs have increased significantly in recent years. The previous government capped BC Hydro rate increases at 3.75 percent for the last two years, and it’s quite possible a bigger “catch up” increase is waiting in the wings.
Still, prioritizing competitive electricity makes sense. However, I think the previous government’s objective to “ensure” BC Hydro’s rates don’t exceed cumulative inflation is too prescriptive, and should be removed. Rates need to be sufficient to cover costs, otherwise we end up with billion-dollar bailouts, as we experienced in 2019 after years of Liberal meddling with rate caps.
And another thing…
There are other changes to the existing Energy Objectives that would further the Conservatives’ growth agenda.
First, soften the objective that 100 percent of electricity used in BC is generated from “clean and renewable resources”. This is desirable, but trying to “ensure” it will limit the sources of both domestic and imported generation, and conflict with the higher priority of economic development.
Second, remove the objective to be a net exporter of electricity. It makes sense to export surplus electricity when we have it. But having net exports as an objective in its own right might lead to over-supply, and unnecessary costs for domestic customers.
Third, remove the objective to avoid using nuclear power. I don’t think anyone seriously expects BC to be generating electricity with nuclear power in the next decade, but excluding it from consideration entirely is myopic.
Finally, reducing GHG emissions is an appropriate objective and should stay. Other things being equal, why wouldn’t we want to reduce emissions from the electricity system? The problem is one of trade-offs. The new government appears to value economic growth above emissions reduction, but that doesn’t justify taking the latter off the list entirely. I would, however, remove the short-term targets (objectives (g)(i) through (g)(v)).
Musical chairs?
Most of the changes above can be done by Cabinet with an Order in Council, as the NDP did in 2024 when it put its own stamp on them, although it requires legislation to remove the GHG emission reduction targets. There is merit in acting fast, as BC Hydro will take time to get its collective head around the changes.
That said, it might be better if all the changes were implemented together as part of new legislation. It would be a more meaningful debate, even if the new government’s majority made the outcome inevitable.
Armed with a new set of priorities, the government should direct BC Hydro to redo its long-term plan to align with them. This needn’t take years, as it usually does, as I’ll explain in a future article.
An interesting question still remains, however. The chairs of both BC Hydro and the BCUC were appointed under the old regime. How enthusiastic will they be about the policy priorities of the new government?
Watch this space.
Attachment 1 – BC’s Energy Objectives
The current list of BC’s Energy Objectives, incorporating the 2024 modifications, is as follows:
(a) to achieve electricity self-sufficiency;
(b) to take demand-side measures and to conserve energy, including the objective of the authority reducing its expected increase in demand for electricity by the year 2020 by at least 66%;
(c) by 2030, to ensure that 100% of the electricity generated in British
Columbia and supplied to the integrated grid is generated from clean or
renewable resources, and to ensure that the infrastructure necessary to
transmit that electricity is built;
(d) to use and foster the development in British Columbia of innovative technologies that support energy conservation and efficiency and the use of clean or renewable resources;
(e) to ensure the authority’s ratepayers receive the benefits of the heritage assets and to ensure the benefits of the heritage contract under the BC Hydro Public Power Legacy and Heritage Contract Act continue to accrue to the authority’s ratepayers;
(f) to ensure the authority’s rates remain among the most competitive of rates charged by public utilities in North America;
(f.1) to ensure that changes to the authority’s rates
(f.1) (i) are reasonably predictable, and
(f.1) (ii) are reasonably consistent from year to year;
(f.2) to ensure that increases to the authority’s rates do not exceed cumulative
inflation
(g) to reduce BC greenhouse gas emissions
(g) (i) by 2012 and for each subsequent calendar year to at least 6% less than the level of those emissions in 2007,
(g) (ii) by 2016 and for each subsequent calendar year to at least 18% less than the level of those emissions in 2007,
(g) (iii) by 2020 and for each subsequent calendar year to at least 33% less than the level of those emissions in 2007,
(g) (iv) by 2050 and for each subsequent calendar year to at least 80% less than the level of those emissions in 2007, and
(g) (v) by such other amounts as determined under the Climate Change Accountability Act;
(g.1) to ensure that the authority holds rights to a sufficient amount of clean or
renewable electricity to enable British Columbia to meet the objective set
out in paragraph (g);
(h) to encourage the switching from one kind of energy source or use to another that decreases greenhouse gas emissions in British Columbia;
(i) to encourage communities to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and use energy efficiently;
(j) to reduce waste by encouraging the use of waste heat, biogas and biomass;
(k) to encourage economic development and the creation and retention of jobs;
(l) to foster the development of first nation and rural communities through the use and development of clean or renewable resources;
(m) to maximize the value, including the incremental value of the resources being clean or renewable resources, of British Columbia’s generation and transmission assets for the benefit of British Columbia;
(n) to be a net exporter of electricity from clean or renewable resources with the intention of benefiting all British Columbians and reducing greenhouse gas emissions in regions in which British Columbia trades electricity while protecting the interests of persons who receive or may receive service in British Columbia;
(o) to achieve British Columbia’s energy objectives without the use of nuclear power.

